Nnmcgonagall vs snape who would win books

Im quite curious to see who would win, especially as smaug is not only arguably a more intelligent foe than the dragons of the hp universe but is also. In a fair duel, the is not a chance that bellatrix would win, minerva is a superior witch with great skill and is in all honestly probably the most powerful witch in the whole of the harry potter. Film snape has his hax cursesplitting blindshot ohko feat, and probably wins. Killing dumbldedore solidified snape s value and loyalty to voldemort. Rowling had created with her harry potter franchise. Snape struggled free of the crushing arms and sent it flying back toward his attackers. He didnt bother closing his mind to mcgonagalls invasion. As an elementalist, the dark arts follow her everywhere she goes and with the dark arts comes dark wizards. Severus snape pros made dark spells as a teen 1 of the best in the world at potions, dark arts, and occlumency he is very talented at. While i dont want to get any further down the essay vs. I dont like the marginalization of women when the fighting breaks out.

Rowling fought for mcgonagalls battle the mary sue. In our very first who would win, we pitted the man of steel against the radioactive godlike watchman, doctor manhattan. Snape can just use a wand, and to do that he needs to be able to hit the target. Later, as a mill worker, he used to read books in the evening, taking great interest in shakespeares plays. Lets see how the new 52 version of dcs most famous justice leaguer fares against marvels blond and brawny god of thunder, thor. Death eaters aim to kill and as mentioned before many of the phoenix members would not do such a thing. Who would win in a battle between 2 of the most powerful witches in the harry potter series. Severus snape replaced professor mcgonagall as headmaster once voldemort was controlling the ministry of magic through pius thicknesse. Throughout the series, particularly in the books, professor mcgonagall disses umbridge with sass, acts like the only adult in the room full of hundredyearold wizards, stuns us with her skill and skill and puts her money where her mouth is. Who would win a duel between severus snape and minerva. In the book, minerva mcgonagall is the one who does it and for me it was.

The only reason we dont see a war is because jkr made this a childrens book story. When harry looked up again, snape was in full flight, mcgonagall, flitwick, and sprout all thundering after him. Take this away, put mcgonagall and snape 1 on 1 and who would win. They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snape seeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but snape too, is very skilled and learned from lord voldemort. Minerva mcgonagall, who we first see in her cat shape, meets with albus dumbledore as baby harry is brought to number 4, privet drive. Dumbledore vs snape poll results severus snape fanpop. They played those characters in all 8 of the harry potter movies. Ahead of the release of the fully illustrated edition of harry potter and the philosophers stone, take a look at the new face of rowlings characters. Batman vs harry potter is a fight by zombieslayer23. The ousting of severus snape also improperly referred to as the sacking of severus snape was a duel between severus snape, then headmaster of hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the hogwarts heads of houses. Aug 26, 2015 even though that scene was not in the books, the conversation was true to her character, and it showed her dry sense of humor. The dark lord indeed is stronger than snape, but he was only sharing bodies with quirrell because he was weak at the time, making snape much stronger and more capable, but if the dark lord was using.

Wizards like snape, tom, and kingsley would do very well against muggles because they know of them and what they are capable of. The kids love them and we always try to guess who will win before we read the book. Harry and luna had to dive sideways to avoid it as it smashed into the wall and shattered. Severus snape pros made dark spells as a teen 1 of the best in the world at potions, dark arts, and occlumency he is very talented at legilimency has almost nothing you can emotionally imbalance with he arguably has the largest arsenal o. It would be a close duel, but mcgonagall would emerge victorious. James was a powerful wizard, but the only reason he could ever beat up snape was because it was three on one. A brief snapemcgonagall duel did take place in hogwarts. Voldemort said to him, i have thought long and hard, severus do you know why i h.

But that doesnt really answer my question about who would win an actual duel. Everyone gives dumbledore so much credit for being the greatest wizard ever, but he had the elder wand for a very long while, which gave him a huge advantage. Of course, i suppose it could be the part where snape is using his mad mindreading powers to find out whether harrys returned to look for a horcrux. Get to know jerry pallotta, author of the kidfavorite who would win. Mcgonagall vs snape, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. Before the battle of hogwarts, flitwick helps to chase severus snape out of the hogwarts castle alongside professors mcgonagall and sprout, and to put protective charms around the castle to hinder voldemort and his oncoming death eaters, and later fights the intruders in the battle, battling corban yaxley and later defeating dolohov. Rowling weighs in on harry potter and the great snape. So, in this article, i wanted to go through all of the reasons why harry potter is appropriate for all ages and doesnt just belong within the confines of elementary school libraries.

Book snape doesnt, mcgonagall seemed to be beating him, and she has more generally impressive feats of magic. This time, were giving superman another chance to prove his might and mettle. That said many members are aurors so i think they could win. Apr 04, 2010 who s better at duel between these two harry potter characters. Not only does minerva mcgonagall command the respect of her students, she is also as close as a confidant as anyone can be to albus dumbledore, with the possible exception of severus snape. He is advanced in potion, he is intelligent enough to invent his own spells. Why didnt severus disapparate in the shrieking shack. In harry potter, who was headmaster after mcgonagall. Find out in this awesome set of 23 books from the wildly popular who would win books series. Muggles guide to harry pottercharactersminerva mcgonagall.

And its our job to look at characters abilities, weapons, and powers to see who would win a death battle twilight sparkle. I was in an orgy with severus snape and albus dumbledore where i buggered his wrinkled old arse and greasy snape buggered. In 1877, mcgonagall suddenly discovered himself to be a poet. Part 2 instead of mcgonagall, who fought snape in the book. An archive of our own, a project of the organization for transformative works. Jerry pallotta is an awardwinning author of childrens books, including what i saw in the teachers lounge, dinosaur christmas, who will guide my sleigh. Snape was the death eater most familiar with hogwarts. Kingsley, slughorn, and mcgonagall duel was that because of harrys sacrifice none of his spells were working properly and yet he still managed to win. The minecraft skin, minerva mcgonagall, was posted by kimminess12. It would simply have been all too easy and rather dark to turn hp series into a war vs muggles and win.

Shes stern, loyal, encouraging, yet unwavering, and my only sadness is. Both moody and snape would be pretty evenly matched but i have a feeling snape might better moody in his skill and precision. Its voldemort vs dumbledore from harry potter folklore subscribe s. There are some things that you should run away from, professor mcgonagall concluded, a bad grade isnt one of them. Contact obscurus books and let them know that godrics journal would be released on the first of december. Snapes daughter harry potter fanfic minerva mcgonagall. For some reason, i cant stop myself from thinking shes stronger than him, if only from those brief moments harry comments on how well she hexes, and i think even ron admits that she does a good bogey hex. Minerva mcgonagallseverus snape works archive of our own. If youve ever read or seen harry potter, you know that minerva mcgonagall is, perhaps, the greatest character in the entire series. Lets put aside the whole plan to kill voldemort, which was obviously a factor as to why snape wouldnt fight back. Images of snape giving his allegiances to dumbledore so lily could be protected, snape tending to dumbledores blackened hand from putting on a cursed ring, snape telling dumbledore he only has a year to live, snape agreeing to kill dumbledore should draco malfoy fail to carry out the deed of the dark lord.

Who would win a wizards duel snape or harry discussion as the title suggests in a proper wzards duel as shown in secrets who would win severus snape. Jul 20, 2011 download the pony game to have a chance to win a harry potter wand. Slughorn finally enters, and mcgonagall informs him that snape is taking a leave of. Voldemort, delphi as she is his daughter and snape. James vs snape barty crouch jr vs neville harry vs bellatrix ron vs draco lucius vs sirius cedric vs pettigrew tonks vs dolohov mcgonagall vs carows rookwood vs kingsley lupin vs yaxley fleur v hermione cho vs ginny snape vs. Snape would win over quirrel even with the dark lords help. Who would win in a duel minerva mcgonagall or alecto.

He would win a lot quicker here and sirius, snape, and bellatrix are only a bit better then mcgonagall. Snape would be cold, calculating, resourceful, and cautious. I think both fights in the movies and books should be disregarded, because. Eyes and books beware this feature is not available right now. This photo is from harry potter and the goblet of fire, i believe. Voldemort, snape, malfoy, petigrew, and karkaroff harry vs. He invented his own and highly skilled spells for use against enemies.

She raised her wand so that it was at eye length to snape. Sure, snape has a magic, but gibbs could kill him from a long distance with a long range rifle, shoot him from medium range with a pistol, stab him close range with his knife rule 9, or simply snap his neck. Hermione was the last person to do anything against the rules, and here she was pretending she had, to get them out of trouble. Snape s power is very real because he practiced it and mastered it all on his own. He is also proven, as book two and six displayed, an immensely talented duelist. I imagine mcgonagall would use a more indirect approach, turning objects into animals to fight for her and so on. Who would win a duel between severus snape and bellatrix. If voldemort and dumbledore were both at full power, who would win. Jan 25, 2008 from harry potter and the philosophers stone the firsyears, professor mcgonagall, said hagrid. Who would win in a death match between james potter and severus snape. Series collection of 8 books by jerry pallotta and. Mcgonagall walked toward snape and stood in front of him. Read minerva mcgonagall from the story snape s daughter harry potter fanfic by allthebruhmoments d with 12,667 reads. Professor mcgonagall is a steadfast professor, who, unlike teachers such as slughorn or snape, cares.

I mean, for starters, she actually is pretty fair when it comes to awarding and deducting house points from gryffindor, which is more than you can say for many other professors. If they met in combat with no outside influence, who would come out on top. With that said, professor mcgonagall sternly went on, youre never going to improve if you leave in the middle of my class. Mar 26, 2018 my favorite character is professor mcgonagall, which ive learned is not a popular opinion. Find out in todays video bellatrix lestrange vs hermione granger. Harry vs snape bellatrix vs mad eye snape vs james sirius vs barty crouch jr remus vs lucius kingsley vs dolohov cedric vs pettigrew draco vs ron tonks vs yaxley snape vs. But i believe snape is slightly more prolific than she. I havent read the last book but we hear neville talk about them in the movie. Jam city, the developers behind the upcoming mobile game harry potter. Snape and mcgonagall both saw the dementor before he came into the room, knew that dumbledore would disapprove and knew what a dementor could do. But as far as feats go, i think both books and movies show snape with far more combat power, prowess, and superior tutelage essentially learning from the two most powerful wizards, dumbledore and voldemort.

She is best known as deputy headmistress of hogwarts and parttime tabby cat, but there is more to learn about professor minerva mcgonagall. I do believe that severus knew he was in danger in the shrieking shack. The series focuses much more on severus snape s magical prowess and his mastery of occlumency which is amazing, but very little information is av. Mcgonagall is gifted in transfiguration, and snape in potions, neither of which are really useful in duel, though from those 2 id say transfiguration has the edge, but snape is also well versed in dark arts, something we dont about mcgonagall, so id say that gives snape the edge. Why couldnt snape and mcgonagall prevent what fudge did at. Legilimens a look of shock flashed in snape s face for a moment but was gone in an instant.

These two famous warner brothers heroes were once normal kids, but after their parents were murdered, they become heroes and eventually avenged their parents deaths. I personally think sirius couldnt defeat either bellatrix or snape. What you have to keep in mind about the voldemort vs. The series focuses much more on severus snapes magical prowess and his mastery of occlumency which is amazing, but very little information is av. Mcgonagall had orders to protect barty crouch, she and snape had time to talk to. She is an all business, no nonsense kind of professor who loves her students more than they will ever know. Jul 28, 2017 arabella knight is the perfect pure blooded daughter everyone wishes for, except her unwillingness to be ruthless. Mcgonagall then sent a orange streak of light at snape, as snape sent a blue streak. What flaws did minerva mcgonagall overcome over the course of the harry potter books. If they went all out on each other and neither could use the killing curse then it would be interesting, but i couldnt say who the final winner would be.

Since then, thousands of people the world over have enjoyed the verse of scotlands alternative national poet. I have also included a personal letter from salazar himself in that book. Who would win books, complete set 23 titles book series for kids bookmarks included jerry pallotta on. When lev grossman put pen to paper for the magicians book series, he was in large part inspired by the expansive world j. Harry, about to curse snape, was forced to pull luna out of the way of the descending flames, which became a ring of fire that filled the corridor and flew like a lasso at snape then it was no longer fire, but a great black serpent that mcgonagall blasted to smoke, which reformed and solidified in seconds to become a swarm of pursuing daggers.

A duel between snape and bellatrix wouldnt simply be a fight between two people, but rather a clash between two archetypical wizarding martial ways. Apr 18, 2016 of the realistic and amazingly developed characters in harry potter, professor mcgonagall is by far one of my favorites. All in all, snape is highly talented with dark magic, mcgonagall doesnt have any significant specialty in defense against the dark arts. Students love predicting who would win in a potential matchup. Quotes by and about minerva mcgonagall the harry potter lexicon. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for an. So mcgonagall and flitwick were obviously trying to overpower snape but snape had to defend himself with the added restriction of not hurting his attackers. So if they were really fighting to the death in a wizarding duel who would win. Download the pony game to have a chance to win a harry potter wand. Five of the most popular books in the who would win.

Snape remained quiet, awaiting the inevitable killing curse. Rowling, on fighting the decision to pit harry potter against severus snape in harry potter and the deathly hallows. They both seem to be better than lestrange, that means all the. People here are only acknowledging the book mcgonagall. Id say hermione she always had a bigger knowledge and memorization of spells and she is very good at them so he. First of all is the fact that the last two books have rolled by without a great villain reveal, such as was with quirrel, tom riddle, peter pettigrew, and crouch. Well, a couple of things have been bugging me, snowballing each time i reread these books. Or rather, snape is commenting on the fact that the slytherin team has beat gryffindor yet again and how he wont need to return the quidditch cup for another year in a row. Harry thinks he must be dead, but mcgonagall bitterly comments that, unlike dumbledore, snape had a wand and has learned a few tricks from youknow who. While snape would likely be more direct with sectumsempra and so on. Snape s skill is more to do with potions, legilimency and occlumency.

As they discuss the recent events that have brought harry there, mcgonagall unsuccessfully argues against dumbledore leaving the infant with his aunt and uncle, calling them, the very worst sort of muggles. Batman vs harry potter death battle fanon wiki fandom. Harry potter and the deathly hallows duel between harry. Ps7 welcome to hogwarts, said professor mcgonagall. Hes also way younger so thats got to count for him as well. I think it worked incredibly well, and the act of allowing neville and seamus to blow up the bridge was an excellent way to show everyone within the school that she was in charge of keeping the students and hogwarts safe. Harry sees a large, batlike figure soaring across the school grounds.

Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower, harry. If it came down to snape and dumbledore minus the elder wand, i think snape would win hands down. Hogwarts mystery, announce its release date and reveal that it will reunite the movie cast. Who would win books, complete set 23 titles book series for.

They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snapeseeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but. Though the series, in its first books, is clearly aimed at children, i believe that its content grows with the characters themselves as well as the readers. The startofterm banquet will begin shortly, but before you take your seats in the great hall, you will be sorted into your houses. Sep 23, 2015 say what you want about albus dumbledore and harry potter being the best characters to walk the halls of hogwarts. Harry would be allowed his firebolt in this fight and would have all the magical knowledge he knew by the time of the battle of hogwarts. Minerva mcgonagall in harry potter and the halfblood prince. Giant squid, one that wasnt shown in the original set, lobster vs. There are only three characters that are powerful enough to fly without a broom. Twilight vs harry potter death battle fanon wiki fandom. Severus snape, especially during the harry potter series, knew more spells, curses, and jixes. Both knew how to do a patronus charm and it seems to me that at least mcgonagall saw the dementor executing the kiss.